The oprah car giveaway of September 13, 2004 is remembered as television’s happiest moment, but for the 276 people in that studio audience, the celebration came with a bill from the IRS. Every winner received a brand-new Pontiac G6 sedan with a retail value of roughly $28,500 — and under federal tax law, that value counted as income.
According to reporting at the time by the Associated Press and the Chicago Tribune, most winners faced combined federal and state income taxes of about $6,000 to $7,000 on the car. Nobody handed them a check to cover it. Harpo Productions told reporters the winners had three choices: keep the car and pay the tax, sell the car and use the money to pay the tax, or turn the car down entirely.
Here’s what actually happened next, according to news reports from 2004 and follow-up coverage since — including who kept their cars, who sold them, and why the same giveaway was handled very differently six years later.
What Happened on Stage That Day
The 19th-season premiere of The Oprah Winfrey Show taped at Harpo Studios in Chicago. Winfrey handed out gift boxes to the audience and told them one contained a car key. When the boxes opened, every box had a key. All 276 audience members had won a 2005 Pontiac G6.
The cars were donated by General Motors’ Pontiac division, which confirmed publicly that it paid for the vehicles out of its marketing budget. Press coverage at the time put the total retail value near $8 million. GM was launching the G6 that fall and wanted the exposure.
As HISTORY has documented in its account of the day, audience members had been selected because show staff believed they needed a reliable vehicle. The emotional reaction on camera — screaming, crying, people needing to sit down — is what made the clip famous.
The Tax Bill Behind the Oprah Car Giveaway
The tax problem in the oprah car giveaway was not a loophole or a mistake. It’s how the U.S. tax code treats prizes. The IRS explains on IRS.gov that prizes and awards are taxable income, reported at fair market value, and included on Schedule 1 of Form 1040 under “prizes and awards.”
Because Pontiac gave the cars to viewers rather than to friends or family, the transfer did not qualify as a tax-free gift. It was a prize from a business. IRS guidance also notes that noncash prizes are valued at fair market value for reporting purposes, and payers issue Form 1099-MISC once the reporting threshold is met.
So each winner was looking at roughly $28,500 added to their taxable income for 2004. What that cost depended entirely on the winner’s own bracket, state of residence, and household situation — which is why published estimates ranged from about $6,000 to about $7,000 rather than landing on one number.
What Winners Actually Did Next
Coverage from the Chicago Tribune and the Associated Press in the weeks after the taping described a range of outcomes. Some winners paid the tax out of savings and kept the car. Others took out a loan against the vehicle to cover what they owed.
A number of winners sold or traded the G6, using the proceeds to cover the tax bill and, in some cases, buying a cheaper used car with what was left. Some accepted a cash amount from the dealership instead of the vehicle. A smaller group reportedly declined the prize.
Pontiac did soften the landing in one respect. News reports at the time confirmed that GM covered state sales tax and licensing costs on the donated vehicles. What GM did not cover was the winners’ personal income tax, which is the obligation that generated the headlines.
Why the Oprah Car Giveaway Story Stuck Around
The oprah car giveaway became shorthand for a lesson that hits sweepstakes winners every year: a prize is not the same thing as cash, but the IRS taxes it as though it were. Tax writers have returned to the episode repeatedly, including a 2016 retrospective by Kelly Phillips Erb at Forbes, precisely because the math is so clean and so relatable.
It also became a case study inside the television industry. In later years, producers who worked on the episode discussed publicly that the tax consequences created real hardship for some recipients and prompted internal debate about how future giveaways should be structured.
The clip itself — “You get a car! You get a car!” — has outlived the show. But the second half of the story, the part that arrives in the mail the following April, is the part most people never saw.
How Later Giveaways Were Handled Differently
The most concrete evidence that the lesson landed came in November 2010. On the “Ultimate Favorite Things” episode, every audience member received a not-yet-released 2012 Volkswagen Beetle. As ABC News and Cars.com reported, Volkswagen covered the applicable taxes and fees on that prize.
📨 Get Free Sweepstakes Alerts
Free · No spam · Unsubscribe anytime
That change was widely and explicitly attributed to what happened in 2004. Instead of leaving winners to fund a five-figure tax obligation on their own, the sponsor built the tax cost into the promotion.
You still see both models in sweepstakes today. Some official rules state plainly that the winner is solely responsible for all taxes. Others include a cash component designed to offset the tax on a noncash prize. The official rules document is where that answer lives, and it is written before anyone wins.
How Prize Taxes Generally Work in the US
This is a description of how the rules operate, not tax advice — for your own situation, the IRS and your state revenue agency are the authorities.
- Fair market value counts as income. IRS.gov states that prizes and awards are included in gross income at their fair market value.
- A 1099 may arrive. Sponsors issue Form 1099-MISC for reportable prize payments, with the amount shown in Box 3, Other Income.
- Reporting applies regardless. The IRS notes that income is reportable whether or not an information return is issued.
- State treatment varies. The state where a winner lives affects the total, which is why per-person estimates in 2004 differed.
If you receive means-tested benefits — SSI, SNAP, Medicaid, Section 8, or similar — reporting requirements generally apply to prizes and other income changes, and how a prize affects eligibility depends on the specific program and your circumstances. The agency administering your benefits is the only place to get an answer for your case.
What Winners Can Learn From This
The factual record from the oprah car giveaway is straightforward. A noncash prize created a real tax obligation. The obligation was disclosed after the fact rather than funded up front. Winners were given options — keep, sell, or decline — and different people chose differently based on what they could afford.
The follow-on record is equally factual: when a comparable giveaway happened in 2010, the sponsor paid the taxes, and reporting at the time connected that decision directly to 2004. The industry response to the oprah car giveaway was a structural change, not a public relations statement.
The documented pattern is that the value of a prize and the cash cost of accepting it are two separate numbers, and only one of them appears on screen.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much did Oprah car giveaway winners pay in taxes?
Reporting from 2004 put the combined federal and state income tax at roughly $6,000 to $7,000 for most of the 276 winners, based on a car value near $28,500. The exact amount varied by each person’s tax bracket and state.
Did Oprah pay the taxes for the winners?
No. Harpo Productions said winners could keep the car and pay the tax, sell it and pay the tax, or decline it. Pontiac covered state sales tax and licensing on the donated vehicles, but not each winner’s personal income tax.
Why were the cars taxed if they were a gift?
The IRS treats prizes from businesses as taxable income rather than tax-free gifts. IRS.gov states that prizes and awards are reported at fair market value on the recipient’s return.
Did winners have to keep the car?
No. According to news coverage from the time, some winners sold or traded the G6 to cover the tax bill, some accepted a cash amount from the dealership instead, and some declined the prize entirely.
Want to put this knowledge to work?
Know the Rules Where You Live
Sweepstakes and prize rules change from state to state — what a sponsor can offer, how prizes are handled, and what protections you have. Pick your state to see the exact rules that apply where you live.
See Sweepstakes Laws in All 50 States →
Sources & How to Verify
The facts on this page are drawn from official government and primary sources. Rules and figures change, so always confirm the current details with the official agency or the promotion’s own published rules.
- FTC Consumer Advice: consumer.ftc.gov — prize, sweepstakes, and lottery scam guidance
- IRS: irs.gov — how prizes and winnings are treated as income
- Social Security Administration: ssa.gov — what SSI recipients must report
- The promotion’s official rules: every legitimate sweepstakes publishes them — the rules page is always the final word
Content last reviewed August 2026. If you notice outdated information, please contact us.
Related Guides
- Sweepstakes Laws by State (50-State Guide)
- More in This Category
- Sweepstakes Resources
- Scam Checks
- Sweepstakes Tax Calculator
- All Active Sweepstakes
Informational only — not legal, tax, or financial advice. Win Big Daily is an independent educational resource. Prize rules, tax treatment, and benefit-program requirements vary by state and program and change over time, so always verify the current details with the official agency, the promotion’s published rules, or a qualified professional before acting. If a topic involves government benefits, contact the program office about your specific situation.